Can you climb without climbing shoes? Sure - in many places, your regular sneakers or hiking shoes/boots will work. This is generally limited to climbing walls with screw in climbing holds or real rock walls up to maybe a 5.6 rating. But for more technical climbing on both indoor walls with artificial climbing holds and rock walls with natural features, climbing shoes make a huge difference and you may not be able to climb without them.
Which shoes do you get? Well, pick ones that fit. The only way you can know if a shoe fits is by trying them on. Don't trust shoe sizes, because they are all over the place. Go to REI or another climbing gear store and try on different shoes. They should fit snuggly without socks on.
Evolv Defy after Year of heavy use by Adult
Many 5.10+ climbs and outdoor multi-pitches
So comfortable, but time for higher performance shoes
Beginner Shode are good up to about grades: 5.6–5.10 / V0–V2. Many adult climbers won't ever get past this point and getting higher performance shoes won't help them that much at this level. If you are just starting out, beninner shoes are all that you need and can actually fit and work much better than performance shoes.
Pick a pair that fits and understand that there is a chance that you will destroy your first pair in a few months or possibly give up on this sport. If you destroy your first pair, you are obviously into climbing and your next pair will last much longer as you start to climb with more skill. If you gave up on climbing, it may be because your picked a shoe that doesn't fit.
La Sportiva Tarantulace - Best Overall Beginner choice
Scarpa Reflex VS - Best Comfortable Velcro option
Black Diamond Momentum - Best Budget Velcro option
La Sportiva Finale - Best Beginner-to-Intermediate shoe
Evolv Defy - Best for Comfort and Gym climbing
Indoor Gym Climbing: Scarpa Reflex VS
Indoor Bouldering: Black Diamond Momentum
Outdoor Bouldering: La Sportiva Tarantulace
Outdoor Sport Climbing: La Sportiva Finale
General-Purpose Climbing: La Sportiva Finale
One important distinction: if you plan to progress into sport, trad, and outdoor climbing, consider starting our with the Finale rather than buying the cheapest beginner shoe and upgrading shortly afterward.
First Pair of Climbing Shoes
Worn through in First 3 months by Youth
Next pair of same shoes lasted a year
Our recommendation is to start with a comfortable, all-around climbing shoe that fits properly, rather than immediately purchasing a specialized shoe for bouldering, sport climbing, or another discipline. As a beginner, you will benefit much more from learning good footwork and developing climbing technique than from having an aggressive, high-performance shoe.
Fit is more important than performance. A comfortable shoe that fits your foot properly will generally serve you better than a more aggressive shoe that is too tight, painful, or poorly suited to your foot shape. This is especially true for climbers in their first year, when technique and foot placement have a much greater impact on performance than specialized shoe features.
Avoid the temptation to buy aggressively downturned shoes or size down excessively in pursuit of better performance. Beginner climbers should prioritize a snug, secure fit without significant pain. Your toes should make contact with the front of the shoe, but they do not need to be severely curled or crushed.
Beginner climbers are often surprisingly hard on their shoes. It is not uncommon to wear through the rubber at the toes or sides in as little as three months of regular climbing, particularly when climbing several times per week.
Much of this wear comes from developing footwork habits. New climbers frequently drag, scrape, and repeatedly reposition their feet against the wall, causing unnecessary abrasion to the shoe's rubber and upper. As technique improves, climbers learn to place their feet more deliberately, use precise foot placements, and rely on controlled movements rather than repeatedly scraping their shoes against the wall.
Your first pair of climbing shoes is partly a learning investment. Expect some additional wear while developing good technique, and don't spend a premium on specialized shoes that you may quickly outgrow in terms of skill or wear through.
Once your footwork improves and you have a better understanding of your preferred climbing style, you can consider investing in more specialized shoes designed for bouldering, sport climbing, trad climbing, or other disciplines.
Shape: Neutral / flat
Downturn: None or minimal
Stiffness: Medium to stiff
Closure: Velcro or laces
Rubber: Durable, approximately 4–5 mm
Toe position: Slightly curled or naturally positioned
Fit: Snug, without painful pressure
Climbing shoes should fit differently from ordinary athletic shoes
Your toes should reach the end of the shoe
Avoid excessive empty space around your toes
Your heel should fit securely without slipping
Your toes can be slightly curled, but should not be painfully compressed
Do not automatically size down one or two sizes. Different manufacturers and models fit very differently
Leather shoes generally stretch more than synthetic shoes
For a beginner, you should be able to wear your shoes for a reasonable climbing session without constantly taking them off because of pain.
For a beginner, the best climbing shoes are generally comfortable, relatively flat (neutral), and moderately stiff shoes that provide good support without forcing your toes into an aggressive position.
You do not need expensive, highly downturned shoes when starting out. A good beginner shoe should work for indoor climbing, gym bouldering, and eventually outdoor climbing.
Our recommendation is to start with a comfortable all-around shoe rather than buying a specialized bouldering or sport-climbing shoe.
Worn out pair of La Sportiva Tarantulace
Best overall beginner choice
Flat, comfortable design
Lace-up closure for adjustable fit
Durable 5 mm rubber
Good for gym and outdoor climbing
Best for: Your first pair of climbing shoes.
Best comfortable Velcro option
Come in Men's and Women's Versions
Neutral, relatively flat profile
Two adjustable Velcro straps
Easy to take on and off
Designed for comfort and gym climbing
Best for: Indoor climbing and bouldering.
Best budget Velcro option
Come in Men's and Women's Versions
Neutral, flat-last design
Breathable knit construction
Two Velcro straps
Comfortable for extended gym sessions
Best for: Beginners who want an easy-to-use shoe.
Best beginner-to-intermediate shoe
Flat, supportive design
5 mm Vibram XS Edge rubber
Lace-up adjustment
Excellent for edging and outdoor climbing
Resoleable
Best for: Beginners who plan to progress into outdoor sport and trad climbing.
Best for comfort and gym climbing
Shoes can be purchased in Lace or Velcro and in Low or Medium Volume
Note the female version (Elektra) is now the low volume version of each shoe
Comfortable synthetic upper
Relatively relaxed shape
Good all-around beginner performance
Vegan construction
Best for: Indoor climbing and climbers who prefer synthetic materials.
These selections balance comfort, support, and progression potential. The Finale is a particularly strong choice if you intend to climb outdoors as well as in the gym.
Best for wide or narrow feet
Neutral, slightly asymmetrical shape
Available in separate wide and narrow fits
4 mm Butora NEO Fuse rubber
Two adjustable Velcro straps
Relatively stiff and supportive
Resoleable
Best for: Beginners looking for a comfortable, supportive all-around shoe, particularly those who struggle to find the right width.
Considerations: Less suitable for steep overhanging terrain.
Best slipper-style option
A Laces option is also available for those who want/need heel security
Slip-on design without laces or Velcro
4.2 mm Stealth C4 rubber
Flexible construction with good sensitivity
Low-profile toe works well for crack climbing
Added toe rubber for improved toe hooking
Resoleable
Best for: Gym bouldering, smearing, and crack climbing.
High level climbers have used this shoe for crack climbing.
Considerations: Less heel security than adjustable shoes (lace version also available). Leather stretches considerably, so proper initial sizing is important.
La Sportiva Mythos
Best for trad and multipitch comfort
Flat, neutral shape
Soft leather upper that molds to the foot
Patented lacing system wraps around the heel
Excellent comfort for extended climbing sessions
Particularly good for crack climbing and smearing
Resoleable
Best for: Traditional climbing, multipitch routes, and long days outdoors.
Considerations: Not as precise or supportive on small edges as stiffer shoes. Leather stretches significantly, requiring careful sizing.
High level and experienced Trad climbers have used this shoe. It is quite comfortable and has good sole.