These recommendations more or less meet the recommendations of the Mountaineers (2024) and are for anyone wanting to complete a Wilderness Navigation Course or who take Wilderness Navigation seriously.
NOTE: These compass recommendations are above and beyond what most Scouts and Adult outdoorsman will need.
Adjustable Declination significantly simplifies map and compass work
Most compasses do NOT have adjustable declination
A declination scale on the compass doesn't mean it has adjustable declination
For declination to be adjustable, the Orienting Arrow (doghouse) MUST move independently of the Meridian Lines (aka orienting lines)
For navigation courses where everyone has a compass with adjustable declination, to include those with the Mountaineers, compasses without adjustable declination distract from learning about navigation
Adjustable Declination with Adjustable Screw vs Toolless
Most quality compasses use a brass adjustment screw for adjusting declination
These require a tiny key, unusually found on the lanyard, to adjust declination
This allows of fine adjustments and makes it difficulty to accidentally change your setting
Toolless compasses use a pinch-to-adjust feature
These are NOT recommended
A transparent base plate allows you to see map features under the compass
It doesn't block out sections of the map
Allows you to better line up orientation lines of the compass with lines on the map
A rectangular shape provides straight edges
These help you plot on a map
A compass with a mirror has an even longer straight edge
Images of Sunnto MC-2 Bezel Variants (from left to right: 360°, Quadrant, Mils)
Image Source: suunto.com
For what we do - you want a compass with a 360° Bezel
A good compass must have a Rotating Bezel
Increments should be 2° or less AND measured from 0 to 360°
Bezel should be large enough to allow you to turn it with gloves on
What NOT to get
0-90° Quadrants
Used for Land Plat Surveys
Makes it easier to plot angles on a map
0-6400 Mils
Mils is short for Mil-Radians
More precise than degrees
Used almost exclusively by the military
Used by artillery, mortars and tanks
Useful when making rough calculations for range and scale
This NOT what we use and will result in confusion
These are found on the bottom side of the compass housing and rotate with the bezel
The run parallel to the north/south axis of the compass housing
These lines help you orient the compass with the grid lines on the map
Most compasses have rulers and gradient scales engraved on the baseplate
U.S. 1:24000 scales are preferred
1:25000 scale is acceptable
Longer baseplates are make map work easier
Anything shorter than 3 inches will limit functionality of the compass
Significantly enhances ability to determine direction to distant targets
Useful on Advanced Navigation Courses
Can be useful when truly lost in the wilderness
Can be useful for Search and Rescue and Military operations
Provided a longer straight edge
Protects the bezel
Can also be used as a signaling device and applying cosmetics
Bad:
Most people will never use a mirror on an actual trip
Adds weight and bulk to compass
Slows down use of compass - important in Orienteering Events
Quality compass with a mirror costs more than one without
Most quality compasses designed for backpackers are liquid filled
Fluid reduced erratic movement of needle by dampening movement
This is particularly important when using a compass while moving
Do NOT swing a compass by its lanyard - a crash can result in a leak
Don't do this with an expensive compass with copper induction-damping either
Allows you to measure slope angles
Nice to have
Refer to the features listed above. A good compass should have the features listed above. The following is a list of compasses that are considered to be acceptable. Keep in mind that designs change over time, as does manufacturing. Swedish made compasses are now made in China and don't perform the same. Also keep in mind that these compasses are more compass than most Scouts or hikers will need.
Made in Finland
Built in Mirror
NON-mirror equivalent Suunto Compass: M-3 NH
Clinometer
1:24000 scale
Long straight edge
Best Choice
Many different versions
Make sure you pay attention to what you are purchasing
Main difference includes:
360 vs Quad vs Mil Bezels
You want 360
Luminous bezel vs black bezel
Scales printed on baseplate:
NH Mirror Compass - CM and Inch
NH USGS Mirror Compass - Inch and USGS
360/IN/D/NH Compass - Inch and Miles
360/D/CM/IN/NH Compass - MM and Inch (1/20 increments)
NH, SH and G Needle
The Compass Needle is balanced to work in a specific part of the world
NH is for use in the Northern Hemisphere
SH is for use in the Southern Hemisphere
Both NH and SH compasses can be used on the equator, but the compass will need to be tilted a bit to get it to work
G uses a Global Needle
Can be used in both Northern and Southern Hemisphere
Can also be used with greater tilt than the other two compasses
See below
Avoid:
Suunto MC-2 Quadrant Compass
Bezel is marked from 0 to 90 from the North and South poles to the East and West Poles
Suunto MC-2/G/6400 Military Compass
Bezel is marked from 0 to 64 instead of 0 to 360
Made in Finland
Built in Mirror
NON-mirror equivalent Suunto Compass: M-3G
Clinometer
Global needle allows this to be used in both Northern and Southern Hemispheres
It also allows you to use the compass that isn't completely level - like when walking
Good if traveling to Patagonia
SS014891000
Best Choice if you have extra money for gear
Avoid:
Suunto MC-2 Quadrant Compass
Bezel is marked from 0 to 90 from the North and South poles to the East and West Poles
SS004252010
Suunto MC-2/G/6400 Military Compass
Bezel is marked from 0 to 64 instead of 0 to 360
SS016326000
Made in China
Clinometer
Built in Mirror
Bad - Declination is obscured
Made in China
Clinometer
Bad - NO Mirror
Bad - Bendable
Made in USA?
Built in Mirror
Inclinometer
Global needle
Bad - Bezel may pop out
Made in USA?
Discontinued
Global needle
Clinometer
Bad - Fewer scales
Bad - Short straightedge
Keep receipt
Return any compass that isn't perfect
Prosight Map Compass from Sun Company
Adjustable Declination is not considered acceptable for Navigation Courses or Wilderness Navigation
Friction held declination
Doesn't "lock" in position like "screw-based" mechanisms
Mountaineers recommend AGAINST using this compass because of adjustable declination design
Glass mirror
Good - doesn't scratch as much
Bad - glass easier to break
Made in Taiwan
Better than China
Not as good and Finland